Επιστήμη του Πνεύματος ENΕΛ
← Articles
Power & Geopolitics

The system wasn't hacked. It got tired.

article 16 •

On 19 July 2024, a security software update from CrowdStrike reached millions of Windows computers at the same moment. It contained one error. Within hours, 8.5 million computers crashed to a blue screen. Flights were grounded around the world, banks stalled, hospitals postponed operations, TV channels went off air. No enemy, no storm. Just one file.

The smarter the system, the dumber the mistake that brings it down.

Old scientific plate in copper engraving: a giant celestial machine of thousands of brass gears, with planets and rings, has stopped. Lower right, inside a dotted circle, a turquoise pebble is wedged between two gears and one tooth has cracked.

Why systems break

A complex system, like an airport, a bank or a power grid, doesn't stay standing because it's smart. It stays standing because it has three safeguards: redundancy, compartments, and people who care. When you cut them to make it more efficient, you don't see it right away. You see it on the day it breaks.

In November 2026, within five days, email, flights and banks went down in the United States. On the 12th, Outlook and the rest of Microsoft 365 were out for almost a full day after a network change. On the 13th, the FAA halted every departure in the country for more than four hours, only the second time since 9/11. The government said new technology had overloaded old communications equipment. On the 16th, a technical problem at JPMorgan Chase rippled through other major banks, and thousands of customers couldn't get into their accounts. So far, in none of the three cases has any sign of an attack been found.

Social media filled up with the usual explanations: a foreign attack, an inside job to justify more control, or plain exaggeration. The idea here offers a fourth one, more mundane and more worrying: wear. If something else lies behind these failures, nobody has shown it. Wear, though, needs no conspiracy to happen.

The first safeguard is redundancy. An airliner carries two pilots, though one is enough to fly it. The hydraulics that move its control surfaces usually run on three independent circuits. To an accountant, that looks like waste. In practice, it's the reason a mistake doesn't become a crash.

The second is compartments. The Titanic had sixteen watertight compartments and could stay afloat with four of them flooded. The iceberg opened at least five, and the bulkheads didn't reach high enough, so the water spilled from one compartment into the next. Compartments mean that when one part fails, only that part shuts down and the rest keep going. If there's a bomb threat in one wing of an airport, you close the wing, not the whole airport. The opposite is the CrowdStrike file: one point, and everything goes down together.

The third safeguard isn't written in any manual. It's the technician who spots something wrong at four o'clock on a Friday and reports it, when he could just go home. It's called professionalism, and it disappears when people feel disposable. In America they call it quiet quitting. In China they call it "lying flat" or "let it rot". The name changes from country to country; the thing stays the same.

When nobody cares, no system holds.

17th-century Dutch oil painting, at night: a dyke watchman sits by his lantern calmly looking at his phone, while behind him the dyke splits open and a torrent of sea water bursts through and reaches his feet.

Why do we cut the safeguards that save us? Because on a spreadsheet each one looks like a cost. The second person on the shift gets laid off in the name of efficiency. Separate systems are merged into one platform, more and more often through AI, because it comes out cheaper. The worker who has watched ten colleagues leave stops going the extra mile. The bank closes the neighbourhood branch and moves everything into the app, and the app goes down on payday.

Behind all this, the same idea goes, three currents are at work. Companies answer to the quarterly profit, so safety is the first line to be cut. The giants have grown so big that nobody inside them is rewarded for good work, only for internal battles. And when the top grows old without leaving, it promotes those who flatter it and pushes out those who make it look small. If the system falls, who pays? Usually nobody.

On the spreadsheet, safety is always a cost. In a crisis, it's the only thing that counts.

I like work: it fascinates me. I can sit and look at it for hours. — Jerome K. Jerome, “Three Men in a Boat” (1889)

There is a way out, though, and it starts with something simple: the three safeguards aren't only for airports. They work at the scale of a household too, and there you're the one in control. You can't fix a country's air traffic control. But you can keep cash in a drawer for when the cards stop working, a second route for anything that now runs through a single point, and a job you do well even when nobody's watching. In every system that still works, there's someone doing a little more than they're asked to.

You can't fix the system. You can be its backup.

Our take

The collapse comes from all three.

17th-century Dutch oil painting, at night: a dyke watchman sits by his lantern calmly looking at his phone, while behind him the dyke splits open and a torrent of sea water bursts through and reaches his feet.

One meme for the road

We are what we pretend to be, so we must be careful about what we pretend to be. — Kurt Vonnegut, “Mother Night” (1961)

We sell nothing.
You keep us going.

No ads, no subscriptions, nothing behind a paywall. If you like what you read, help it keep going.

  • hosting
  • images
  • time for research
as much as you like, whenever you like